If I’m honest, it sounds like a mess. More and more, I’m thinking that STAR is a better system.

  • PhilipTheBucketOPMA
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    15 days ago

    I like STAR because:

    • More understandable. It’s almost as simple as, whoever gets the most stars wins. There’s still an algorithm involved but the explanation doesn’t start with the algorithm.
    • Voters can more accurately represent their preference. 5 star / 4 star / 1 star is different from 5 star / 1 star / 1 star and those are both common things to want in a three-way election.
    • Simpler tabulation, no shipping ballots around and recomputing everything in a central location.
    • No weird Condorcet situations where the wrong person wins.

    Proportional representation is something different. I think that would be excellent in the United States, but unfortunately we’re going back to having a king at this point, so big reforms to the voting system might have to wait until that gets sorted out which might take a few years or decades and maybe a civil war. Hope everyone brought their helmets.